BLOG

Performance Art by Kevan Breitinger

I’ve been wondering for a while now about the incessant clapping between songs during Sunday morning worship. I’m not sure how this strange trend started, but it’s always made me uncomfortable. Coincidentally, it seems to have started right around the time worship music hit the commercial market in a big way, and I’ve wondered also if there is a connection between these two developments. Exactly who is being applauded on Sunday morning? You want to assume it’s God, but it never really feels that way to me.

I visited a church in my area for the first time yesterday, one that has been growing rather explosively. It was the snappy ad in the paper that drew me, something about ‘experiencing the power of God.’ …In a word, NOT. It was actually more like an extended period of elevator behavior. You know, where everyone stares straight ahead in a zombie-like trance of extreme isolation? Even the clapping felt a bit robotic. But when the pastor mentioned being ‘back-stage,’ I felt a chill rundown my spine.

Yes, in one sense it’s just a word, a descriptive term of location. But could it also serve to explain a central shift in our worship perspective? Worship as performance rather than devotion? A friend had recommended the church to me, saying that it was ‘like going to a concert.’ Unfortunately, it was exactly like that. The final nail in the coffin was when we were singing “I Could Sing of Your Love Forever” following the sermon. The lead guitarist leaned into the mic and thanked us for coming, at which point the singing stopped mid-song (I kid you not!) and the robots, um, I mean, the people turned immediately to the aisles and left, quickly and rather silently. Apparently ‘forever’ wasn’t even the full three minutes. This song was not so much an expression of adoration as a part of the closing ceremony.

At what point did the audience of One come to mean ourselves?

2 Responses to “Performance Art by Kevan Breitinger”

  1. Jimmy Wilson Says:

    As a worship leader I too have experienced this phenomenon. I wondered also whether they were applauding my team or God. Being as my team and I are not too polished or professional I assumed it was God. While reading Kevan’s blog I thought of a third possibility. They are possibly applauding the song, or rather the way the song makes them feel. It almost sounds good doesn’t it. Except that when I think about it,is that the purpose of worship? To make us feel good ? Worship isn’t about anything to do with us. Worship is not supposed to take you someplace, it’s not supposed to prepare you for anything, worship is an end in itself. Worship is about God !Worship is for God? Drawing near of the heart to God means the coming alive of our feelings for God. Worship is an affair of the heart. It is an affair of feeling and of emotion. Says John Piper in a sermon from 1981.He went on to say, Jesus said, “This people honors me with their lips, but their heart is far from me.” Therefore, even though worship can refer to a form of activity in which the heart is distant, yet true worship which delights God is the drawing near of the heart to God, or, to put it another way, the quickening of the heart with genuine feelings in response to God’s glory. Such feelings are never performances of will power calculated to accomplish other ends. They are ends in themselves. Therefore, since they constitute the heart of genuine worship, worship is an end in itself.
    So in summary, are we any closer to the answer? Is this applause for God? I am sure that much of it is given by those whose hearts are far from God, but perhaps one person connected with the heart of God, and the emotions overflowed into an expression of that joy that became an honor of applause. The rest only joined out of a type of contagious applause started by the one. And God heard that one loud and clear over the emptiness of the others. I am the eternal optimist. Praise God. ( Clap, Clap!!)

  2. kevan Says:

    Yes, you ARE an optimist. I think it all started, oh, I’d say, maybe about April of 2006? GIVE ME MY SOUL BACK!

Leave a Reply

All content, text, & graphics © 2001-2005, SASP, Inc.